I am trying to debug an issue with audio playback in MuseScore. During this process, I realised that I had/have no clue about audio playback in Linux (or in general for that matter).

I already learned about the differences between ALSA and Pipewire (or PulseAudio for that matter) and what JACK is supposed to do (I think). However, I am not sure if everything (or anything) is configured correctly.

Before this issue I never had any issues with audio playback and I assume my system must have been in a default configuration state. The main clue for the MuseScore issue is an error of the form "audio output open failed." In an attempt to pin the issue down, I learned about aplay and discovered that this did not work out-of-the-box. For some reason aplay tried to use my USB Microphone as the default playback device and failed (unsurprisingly).

After adding a configuration file under /etc/asound.conf specifying the soundcard (of the motherboard) should be used as default, things seemed to work. However, after a restart and attempting playback in MuseScore, I learned that I had opened the gates to hell. Although I believe I perceived some traces of what I expected to hear, I was treated with noise that was way louder and lasted longer than necessary. This latter is to be taken literally: it didn't stop immediately when I paused but went on for multiple seconds.

Due to the mentions of JACK in the issue thread on Github, I wanted to repeat the aplay experiments with JACK. I quickly learned that I could use aplay -D jack to play through JACK (after I started a JACK server of course). The JACK server was started using the command jackd -r -d alsa -d hw:1,0, where hw:1,0 specifies my sound card. This seemed to be necessary because JACK seems to ignore the ALSA default. This is the point where I was again met with a sequence of problems:

1. Playback of my 16-bit/44.1kHz test.wav file failed because JACK only seems to support 32-bit.
2. After creating a 32-bit version of the file, I got stuttering audio with a warning about a sample rate mismatch.
3. The warning suggested to use aplay -D plug:jack instead, which resulted in (differently) stuttering audio without a warning. I also tried to play the original 16-bit file out of curiosity and this also worked (with stuttering).

I have been spending more time than I care to admit to figure all of this out. Although I managed to get sound out of JACK, it is pretty useless in its current state. Therefore, I suspect that I am missing some crucial insight(s). Am I using JACK in the wrong way, is it just a matter of configuration or are there better ways to debug audio issues? I am open to any suggestions, hints or insights!

PS: I am on Arch linux using PipeWire as the main audio server.

posted 9 months ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

9mo ago

mr Tsjolder‭

151 reputation 4 6 18 4